| Week | Episode | Results |
|---|---|---|
November 10 - 16, 2013 |
Season 4 - Episode 34: "The Second Ending" |
#9 Best Web Series Episode |
| January 20 - 26, 2013 | Season 3 - Episode 33: "The Second Beginning" | #2 Best Web Series Episode #3 Best Actor: Timmy DeCoff (Michael Arlington) #3 Best Actress: Mary Paolino (Miriam Arlington/Erica Thomas) |
| January 13 - 19, 2013 | Season 3 - Episode 32: "Awake" | #3 Best Web Series Episode #4 Best Actor: Evan Konstantine (Agent Eric Goyle) #4 Best Actress: Mary C. Ferrara (Gloria Jackson) |
| January 6 - 12, 2013 | Season 3 - Episode 31: "Open Eyes, Open Minds" | #2 Best Web Series Episode #2 Best Actor: Evan Konstantine (Agent Eric Goyle) #3 Best Actress: Eva Davenport (Hayley Warren) #5 Best Actress: Susan T. Travers (Det. Hannah Jones) |
| December 16 - 22, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 30: "A Heart for a Heart" | #2 Best Web Series Episode #2 Best Actress: Susan T. Travers (Det. Hannah Jones) #5 Best Actress: Mary C. Ferrara (Gloria Jackson) |
| December 9 - 15, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 29: "Spiritual Advisors" | #8 Best Web Series Episode |
| December 2 - 8, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 28: "Not My Body" | #3 Best Web Series Episode |
| November 11 - 17, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 27: "The Devil's Deal" | #6 Best Web Series Episode #4 Best Actor: Paul Kandarian (Hunter Jackson) #5 Best Actress: Susan T. Travers (Det. Hannah Jones) |
| November 4 - 10, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 26: "A Child's Game" | #5 Best Web Series Episode #5 Best Actress: Susan T. Travers (Det. Hannah Jones) |
| October 28 - November 3, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 25: "Scary People" | #2 Best Web Series Episode #1 Best Actress: Susan T. Travers (Det. Hannah Jones) #2 Best Actor: Daniel Lee White (Det. James Henderson) #4 Best Actor: Paul Kandarian (Hunter Jackson) #4 Best Couple: Det. Adam Hartt (Timothy Bonavita) and Det. Hannah Jones (Susan T. Travers) |
| October 14 - 20, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 24: "Letting Him Go" | #5 Best Web Series Episode #3 Best Actress: Susan T. Travers (Det. Hannah Jones) |
| October 7 - 13, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 23: "Bloody Paths" | #6 Best Web Series Episode #5 Best Actress: Susan T. Travers (Det. Hannah Jones) |
| September 30 - October 6, 2012 | Season 3 - Episode 22: "The End" | #4 Best Web Series Episode #5 Best Actor: Daniel Lee White (Det. James Henderson) |